What’s the point of comparing childhoods? Let’s get with the times!

If we’re gonna blame social media for all of society’s problems, shouldn’t we be blaming Slimer for teaching us such poor table manners?
SOURCE:GIPHY

I grew up in the 90’s. I was obsessed with Ghostbusters, I collected “Pogs”, I had devil sticks and I watched “Are you Afraid of the Dark” on YTV every Saturday night. One of my favorite things was staying up late to watch all of my favorite music videos on Much Music and MTV. Oh, and who can forget, when I wanted to play with my friends, I knew that phoning their house at 9:00 pm would possibly result in getting yelled at by their parents for calling so late.

Okay good, he’s in a good mood this time!
SOURCE: GIPHY

The struggle was real.

Yet, nowadays, I look at kids, and I have no idea what to think of the trends that they’re into.

What happened to skateboards? Why is everyone longboarding now

Dub step? Really? Have you HEARD of 90’s hip hop, people?!

PewDiePie? I mean really? You’d rather WATCH someone play a videogame on YOUTUBE than actually play the game yourself?

Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you PewDiePie. I still don’t get it…
SOURCE: GIPHY

I just… don’t get it.

Maybe… just maybe…

No… it can’t be.

I think it finally happened guys… I’m officially OLD.

Ah man…I should have seen it coming.
SOURCE: GIPHY

So where does this come into our EC&I 830 class? Well, that’s a great question. This week we had two great debates, one of which asked the question “is social media ruining childhood?”

Although this question is tackling a modern-day issue, we’ve seen many versions of this argument come up in history. Whether it was Elvis being blamed for corrupting the youth of the 50’s with his dance moves, to people pointing the finger at violent videogames and Marilyn Manson for causing the Columbine shootings, we’re always seeking someone or something to blame on our kids’ actions.

The devil is… Elvis?
SOURCE:GIPHY

Nowadays, it’s social media that’s in the spot light. They say that it’s taking away our kids’ innocence. Kids are growing up faster, are being sexualized sooner, and are being exposed to extremely graphic content earlier than ever. Social media (and the internet) are ruining our kids’ childhoods.

Although I definitely agree that some aspects of social media are definitely contributing to children’s shift in behaviors, my classmate Amy made a couple of great points in her blog that are worth considering:

“To me, blaming social media for the arbitrary “moral decline” which is apparently occurring is reminiscent of ‘shooting the messenger’. It is the scape goat, used by those in power to place blame away from a real issue, which is social inequality that leads to the hyper-sexualization of our children and the objectifying of our young girls.”

My other classmate Shannon , takes a similar angle and examines the way companies are finding ways to market towards tweens.

“More concerning to me, however, is the increased sexuality placed on this age group. The pressure for girls of this age to look and act like teenagers is overwhelming.”

Great point!

I never really considered the capitalist side of the argument, but if we’re trying to sell anything to kids nowadays, let’s be honest here, it’s become a hundred times easier than ever before. Social media feeds on sites such as Facebook and Instagram are now littered with personally-tailored ads. Not only are we being fed ads constantly, the ads are actually curated and geared towards your specific age, sex, demographic and personal interests. Companies have so many new and effective ways of reaching their audiences, that avoiding it is becoming harder and harder.

The same can be said about graphic content. Although parental locks can be enabled, these systems are not fool-proof, and content such as pornography can be incredibly easily accessed by kids. Social media feeds aren’t perfect either, and are often crammed with sexually-charged, vulgar or explicit content. If kids want to see it, they’re going to see it (even if they aren’t looking for it).

Amy makes another interesting point by stating how our knowledge is constantly evolving and how important it is that we adjust to these changes. She uses a great example that really stuck with me. Before people knew how bad smoking was, we were smoking indoors in restaurants, airplanes and even schools. Her argument is that once our knowledge shifted, and we became aware of how bad smoking was for everyone, these social norms changed dramatically. In Canada, you’re not going to see a smoking section in a restaurant anymore, and we’re more than likely not going to go back to our old ways now that we know the damage smoking causes.

Social media is one of these changes that we need to adjust to. We’re aware of how much it’s distracting us, we’re aware of the amount of online risks we’re being exposed to, how much time they are spending in front of screens, we know it can negatively affect our mental and physical health (here and here), and we’re aware of the social effects it’s having on our communication skills.

SOURCE:GIPHY

So what are we going to do about it?

Shannon mentions how it’s absolutely crucial that parents play an active role in what their kids are seeing and how they are using social media and the internet. If we don’t want our kids glued to the computer screens, we’re going to have to start modeling better behavior, and that obviously starts with parents and teachers.
Another part of the solution would be for older generations to learn how to use and apply these tools. If our kids are using social media constantly, shouldn’t we know how to use it too? Furthermore, with my following example, I think another big adjustment we need to make is actually addressing social media with our kids as early as possible.

On Friday, I asked several of my classes what they knew about social media. The answers weren’t surprising: they knew everything about it. Why? Because this is what it’s like growing up in 2016; everyone is connected and everyone is using social media, especially kids. What surprised me the most however was when I asked my grade 4/5 class to list off all the social media sites that they either knew about, or used. I’m officially out of the loop. My youngest group of students created a list of 20+ social media sites. They even started listing dating sites. I actually had to ask them what some of these sites were. I was completely dumbfounded.

What I did find out from my little experiment is that this specific group of kids has already dealt with a lot of the risks you’d come to expect from the internet. Many kids have received messages from older strangers; some kids have been asked to share their phone numbers, pictures or personal information with people they don’t know; most of them know what pornography is; and many have seen graphic or explicit content through social media.

Now, when I look back at my grade 4/5 years of schooling, neither of those years included much of any of those things I just mentioned.

Of course, I wasn’t using social media at that age either, and whatever internet I did have, definitely wasn’t capable of producing some of the things they are being exposed to now. This is very important information to consider. My childhood was extremely different, even though I have spent half my life on social media, these kids were born straight into it. What this tells me is that we do need to start addressing these issues at a much younger age. Yes, social media is definitely making our kids grow up quicker, but part of the issue is that we need to start looking at it for what it is, and not comparing it to what we had when we were younger. Times have changed, and with this change, we need to also change with it.

Ask any older generation and they will all tell you something different about their childhoods. I feel like I can’t even say anything about generation Z’s childhood, because quite frankly, I don’t really have any place in it. What I can do however is learn from them, talk to them and discover what growing up in 2016 is really like. Part of the reason I often find myself not “getting” kids, is because I’m slowly being left behind. If I didn’t proactively try to learn as much as possible from these kids, I’d have no idea what half the trends nowadays are about.

In closing, I really don’t think social media alone can be blamed for ruining our kids childhoods. First of all, we’re living in a time where social media is everywhere. This is how people communicate with each other now. It’s not like we’re going to go back to using land lines and getting yelled at by our friend’s parents for calling too late. We’ve got this technology in front of us and kids are using it more than ever now, it’s time to accept it and shift with it.

Maybe kids these days will never know what it was like growing up without internet, cellphones or social media, but let’s be honest, do they really have to? Isn’t this all just the natural progression of humanity and technology? Maybe instead of living in the past, we start learning about these things ourselves, start using them and understanding them. I mean, we might as well see what all the fuss is about right?

Thanks for reading everyone,

Dre

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “What’s the point of comparing childhoods? Let’s get with the times!”

  1. Awesome post! I agree with you. We are not going to regress. There are going to be more avenues for these kids. I think it is important that you suggest “these kids are born into it”. They don’t have any other perception of the world. I think for the number of kids online and interacting we are not really giving them enough credit for how much they know and how they are applying general respect and safety lessons with explicitly being taught in lots of cases. I also agree with you that we need to open up the conversation to our kids to figure our what they are actually using and engaging in.

    I have to laugh at your animation of being old. Being almost the youngest on staff and feeling old sucks!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Hahahha no kidding hey! Well, when I was talking to my grade 4/5’s, I definitely think they are a good representation of what kids are becoming. In contrast with my 7/8’s, there’s already a big difference. For one, the older guys were introduced to social media at a young age, whereas these kids in grade 4 have had a lot of the newer and more modern versions of social media from the moment they were able to use devices. The older kids obviously have a great hand at these things, probably at the same height as the grade 4’s, but there are differences that will probably make a bigger impact on their lives in the long run. I think what I’m trying to get at is, even if there’s a gap of three or four years, the grade 8 students in my class didn’t have snapchat or Instagram (or other similar types of social media) when THEY were in grade four. So already, these grade four kids will already be MORE immersed in social media than kids just a couple of years older than them. I use teaching as a learning Opportunity, Especially if I’m dealing with newer tech or online trends such as newer forms of social media. I need to keep learning this stuff, because regardless of how “up to date” I think I am, I’m always three steps behind somehow. Also, it puts the whole “ruining your childhood” into perspective. These kids are gonna grow up with entirely different lives than any of us, but when they’re older, they’re going to reminisce of the “simpler times” when they would simply snap chat with a friend rather than using some sort of telekinetic tech that we’ll probably have in twenty or thirty years. Hahahha who knows how it’s going to look, but even generation Z is going to be saying the same stuff YOU, ME and our grandparents said once upon a time. It’s just all relative in the end.

      Like

  2. Great post! I think you are totally right that as adults we need to make a conscious effort to learn about social media to connect with youth. Social media is everywhere and it’s not leaving any time soon. So for many stubborn adults I think the phrase “if you can’t beat them, join them” is appropriate. We need to be involved in our kids lives to guide them in the right direction.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. I LOVE that! I was totally gonna wrap up my post by saying that, because it’s definitely the way I feel about society. We’re no longer in a time of uncertainty, we KNOW where society is going with technology. Everything is rapidly changing and if we’re not playing catch up, we’re going to be left behind in the dust. I’ve learned so much from my kids, especially all these weird trends that I’ve had a hard time wrapping my head around. If we’re not engaging with our students and learning about them and THEIR culture, we’re showing Them that their lives don’t matter. Truthfully speaking, it’s US who need to GET WITH it, because we’re the ones that are slowly being phased out. If we know how to use these things, first of all, we bridge the age gap, and secondly, it allows us to guide them a little better. Again, no use in bringing our childhoods into the conversation (other than for educational or conversational purposes). As much as kids aren’t going outside as some of us did growing up, they are doing some interesting things with their free time that can’t be automatically classified as “useless”. It’s time to value generation z and stop talking down on these so called childhoods. Once we start understanding what their lives are actually like, our perspectives might start to shift a bit. Again, this has been happening forever and will most likely keep reproducing Itself throughout history. Thanks for the great reply!

      Like

  3. Awesome post, Andres! Love all the visuals that accompany your points. I liked that you consulted with your classes about this topic, and included their thoughts/feedback in your blog post. This made me think! I also would like to do the same in one of our remaining blog posts! Very well done!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks dales, I appreciate the kind words and feedback. I had a nice follow-up discussion with the grade 4/5 group today, which went pretty well. We talked about everyone’s different perspective on what a “good” childhood is. We also imagined what it’ll be like for THEM in twenty or so years when THEY will be judging THEIR kids on the very same things we’re currently judging them for. These debates have definitely opened my eyes to so many issues I wasn’t really paying attention to. Thanks for the tip in joining this class, it rules!

      Like

  4. Interesting thoughts Dre. I think it’s important we consider what kids are exposed to at such an early age for sure. I definitely feel like I am behind the times when it comes to Internet trends. The kids keep me young.

    Like

    1. On a serious note, you raise a big reality. It’s natural that the wider our age gap is with younger kids (such as our students), our understanding or appreciation for their culture is either fragmented or non existent at all. I enjoy talking to the kids about these things because they are so interested and passionate about them, they always want to share them with you. It’s a fun way to connect with younger generations, and I enjoy having them breakdown new trends to me. Thanks for the reply Luke!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s